Social Security told me I had an overpayment. What do I do?
- If you believe that Social Security is incorrect about the overpayment, or you do not understand how they calculated the overpayment, you can appeal.
- If you believe that Social Security is correct about the overpayment but you do not believe it was your fault and you are unable to pay the money back, you can apply for a waiver.
This result doesn’t match what Social Security told me.
There are a few reasons why this may be happening: first, click on ‘earnings’ at left to make sure that the earnings record and pension amount you uploaded is correct.
If you believe that Social Security has an error in your earnings record, you should contact Social Security and bring evidence of your earnings record to have them correct the error.
Your results may also be affected by the Government Pension Offset, or another Social Security rule not covered by this calculator.
What is the Windfall Elimination Provision (WEP) and how does it affect government workers like teachers or firefighters?
WEP is a complicated provision that alters benefits of retirees who spent some part of their career not paying into social security, often working for state or local government.
Along with the somewhat simpler GPO (Government Pension Offset) rules, they can often catch retirees in Massachusetts and 7-10 other states off guard. This calculator aims to improve the experience for these and other retirees in the United States.Read more at Mass Retirees.
What is the Detailed Calculator or AnyPIA-JS?
Written and maintained since the early 2000s, the official Social Security Administration's Detailed Calculator is a comprehensive benefit calculator which is designed to compute historical benefits as well as estimate future benefits.
For short, it is known as AnyPIA.exe in Windows.
The Windfall project's own calculator could not determine future benefit for people more than a year or so away from retirement eligible age—62 years old. That calculation requires synthesizing predictions from the annual Social Security Trustee report, locating details such as: anticipated economic trends, changes in the trust fund, and adjustments in cost of living.
Screenshot of original desktop Windows version of AnyPIA.
The My SocialSecurity.gov website allows Social Security card holders to download all their earnings records at once, as a PDF or XML file. The information is sourced from the card holder's tax filings. One challenge for card holders who want to plan ahead for their retirement is that the current AnyPIA Detailed Calculator can only load an old format called ".pia", but it cannot load either the XML or the PDF file. This means that the best tools for planners are out of sync with each other. Basically, with existing official tools, retirees always have to track down and manually type in their entire career earnings.
To solve this problem Code for Boston volunteers and Congressman Seth Moulton's office case workers built AnyPIA-JS. It can do the best calculations and take the card holders' most convenient data, so that they can get the most accurate benefits calculation. We also provide other helpful contextual information from caseworkers's interviews with 300 constituents.